Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (2024)

Reuben Chicken is a quick chicken recipe that cooks in 15 minutes and in 1 skillet. This low carb take on the classic is mouthwatering!

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe 17 Comments

This post may contain affiliate links.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (1)

We ate hot sandwiches for dinner constantly while growing up, especially as teenagers when my brothers and I were usually home for no more than 30 minutes most nights before running off to various practices, games, and lessons. Grilled cheese, hot ham and cheese, and Reubens were my Mom’s specialties, and most importantly, they took nearly no time to cook.

I had a massive craving for a hot and sizzling Reuben sandwich around St. Patrick’s Day but couldn’t find gluten free deli corned beef anywhere so I recently satisfied my appetite with 15-Minute Reuben Chicken instead. This quick-cooking chicken dinner recipe is not only made in just one skillet but it is SO so delicious – I’m claiming upgrade!

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (2)

Chicken breasts or cutlets are sauteed then topped with sauerkraut, homemade Thousand Island dressing, and swiss cheese. One pan, packed with flavor, ready in just 15 minutes. It does not get better than this!

Tips for Making Reuben Chicken

  1. Chicken Cutlets vs Chicken Breasts. I love using chicken cutlets, which are large chicken breasts that have been sliced in half widthwise, for this dish because it’s a great way to stretch chicken, plus they cook super fast. If you’re using chicken breasts instead, be sure to pound them out to an even thickness before cooking to ensure they cook evenly.
  2. Homemade Dressing.Russian dressing is commonly used inside Reuben sandwiches, but here in the heart of the Midwest, my Mom always used Thousand Island. The recipe for my homemade version calls for fridge and pantry staples, and is ridiculous tasty. Use leftover sauce for topping burgers. YUM.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (3)

How To Make This Recipe

Start by seasoning chicken breasts or cutlets with homemade seasoned salt and pepper then saute until golden brown on the bottom.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (4)

Flip the chicken then continue sauting for 1-3 minutes, depending on if you’re using cutlets or breasts, and then start adding all the traditional toppings: sauerkraut followed by homemade Thousand Island dressing.Russian dressing is typically used to make Reubens but my Mom always used Thousand Island growing up. You can use either!

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (5)

For the Thousand Island dressing, combine mayonnaise (I used vegan mayo,) ketchup, vinegar, minced dill pickles and white onion, plus a pinch of sugar and a drizzle of pickle juice. That’s it! You can make the dressing ahead of time to get this quick-cooking dish on the table even faster.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (6)

Here’s the kruat I like too. It’s raw, and crunchy, and sour, and I ate half of it with a fork straight outta the bag the first time I bought it. YOLO.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (7)

Last step is to add a slice of swiss cheese to the tops then place a lid on the skillet and continue to saute until the cheese melts.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (8)

HELLO LOVER!!

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (9)

Scoop the chicken onto plates then serve with a fresh side salad or roasted vegetables – roasted asparagus would be absolutely divine next door. However you serve it up, I hope you love this tasty twist on a classic reuben – enjoy!

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (10)

More Craveable Chicken Recipes

  • BBQ, Avocado, Bacon and Cheddar Chicken
  • Mozzarella Bruschetta Chicken
  • Cheesy Everything Bagel Chicken
  • Leek and Mushroom Chicken Skillet

free email bonus

Dinner Made EASY

5 days of simple yet flavorful recipes that take the stress out of dinnertime!

SUBSCRIBE

Reuben Chicken

  • Print
  • Pin It

gluten free15 minute meal20 minute meal30 minute meal

5/5 (2 REVIEWS)

Description

Reuben Chicken is a quick chicken recipe that cooks in 15 minutes and in 1 skillet. This low carb take on the classic is mouthwatering!

Ingredients

serves 4

  • 4 chicken breasts or cutlets (see notes)
  • homemade seasoned salt and pepper
  • 3/4 cup sauerkraut, drained (I use Cleveland Kraut)
  • 4 slices swiss cheese
  • For the Thousand Island Dressing:
    • 1/2 cup mayonnaise (I use Hellman’s Vegan Mayo)
    • 2 Tablespoons ketchup
    • 2 Tablespoons minced dill pickles
    • 1 Tablespoon minced white onion
    • 2 teaspoons white wine vinegar OR distilled white vinegar
    • 1 teaspoon sugar
    • 1 teaspoon pickle juice

Directions

  1. Combine all ingredients for homemade Thousand Island Dressing in a dish then cover and refrigerate. Can be done several days ahead of time.
  2. Place a large skillet over heat that's just a touch above medium then spray with nonstick spray. Season chicken on both sides with homemade seasoned salt and pepper then add to the skillet and saute until golden brown on the bottom, 2-4 minutes depending on the thickness of your chicken cutlets/breasts. Turn heat down to medium, spray tops with nonstick spray, then flip chicken and saute for 1 more minute (2-3 minutes if using breasts vs cutlets.)
  3. Add toppings to each piece of chicken - roughly 2-3 Tablespoons sauerkraut, 2-3 Tablespoons dressing, plus a slice of swiss cheese - then place a lid on top and continue to saute until cheese has melted and chicken is cooked through.

Notes

  • You can use chicken cutlets (large chicken breasts cut in half widthwise,) or chicken breasts depending on how hungry you are! If you use chicken breasts be sure they have been pounded to an even thickness to ensure even cooking.
  • Click here for my 4-ingredient homemade seasoned salt recipe >

This recipe is courtesy of Iowa Girl Eats, http://iowagirleats.com.

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (11)

PREVIOUS Is It Gluten Free? View Post
NEXT 10 of Ben’s Favorite Recipes View Post

Home / Recipes / One Pan

join the conversation

Leave a Comment

17 Comments

  1. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (12) Kathy 04.27.2023

    My husband is wheat allergic and I have to watch sodium because of heart issues, and we love Reubens. To have this with no bread for him and avoiding the corned beef for me, yet tasting like a Reuben was wonderful!

    Reply

  2. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (13) chrissy 02.14.2023

    Great recipe! I’ll be trying this with turkey cutlets and boneless chicken thighs! Thanks Kristen❤️

    Reply

    • Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (14) Kristin 02.15.2023

      Fabulous! I hope you love it, Chrissy!

      Reply

  3. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (15) Nora 03.22.2020

    This recipe was so good! We enjoyed this with roasted potatoes and brussel sprouts! I also cooked par cooked the chicken breasts ahead of time by poaching it in the sauerkraut juices and chicken broth to make it extra juicy and tender, definitely recommend!

    4.5

    Reply

  4. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (16) Adam 05.07.2019

    Thank you for sharing this recipe with us, this recipe is really very mouthwatering. And this unique recipe is very helpful. Though the Reuben Chicken Gluten is not so easy but you give an easy way. This will be helpful for those who want to try a new item of chicken and the steps are so easy. That anyone can cook this. You use combine mayonnaise, minced dill pickles and pickle juice and those are my favorite, I’ll try this at my home.

    Reply

  5. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (17) Jill 04.21.2019

    This looks delcious!!! Wow. Also, Boar’s Head makes Gf corned beef, which can be sliced for you at the grocery’s deli counter. All of their deli meats and cheeses are GF.

    • Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (18) Kristin 04.22.2019

      I just saw that sign at our grocery store’s deli the other day, actually! Good to know! They also say they can’t guarantee anything sliced back there won’t be contaminated with allergens including gluten/wheat though. I *think* you can call ahead to have meat sliced on a clean slicer though.

      Reply

  6. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (19) Istuke 04.11.2019

    Gluten free sliced uncured angus corned beef (no nitrites or nitrates) at Sams Club near meat section. There are several other similar GF sandwich meats there too Enjoy! Thank you!

    Reply

  7. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (20) 15-Minute Reuben Chicken – Recipes Today 04.09.2019

    […] article 15-Minute Reuben Chicken appeared on Iowa Girl Eats. […]

    Reply

  8. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (21) Sarah 04.08.2019

    Made this Reuben Chicken this weekend – delicious!!! I make most of your recipes and they are always good. This was fun, original, easy

    5

    Reply

    • Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (22) Kristin 04.09.2019

      Yay!! I’m so glad you loved it, Sarah!!

      Reply

  9. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (23) Jessy 04.03.2019

    Your writing is very funny hahaha well done on setting up the room!! :)
    that chicken looks amazing though!

    dorky-and-weird.blogspot.com

    xoxo <3

    Reply

  10. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (24) Lisa Lansink 04.03.2019

    This looks delicious!

    Reply

  11. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (25) Arlene Johnson 04.02.2019

    You can find a delicious gluten free corned beef at Sam’s club. I cooked one in my crock pot , cooked in co*ke cola added veggies, cooked on low all day,, and it was so tender.

    Reply

    • Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (26) Kristin 04.02.2019

      That sounds so delicious!! Have you found any GF sliced packaged corned beef (vs the roast)? That’s what I was on the hunt for to use in my reuben sandwich!

      Reply

  12. Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (27) Bry Jaimea 04.02.2019

    I LOVE a good reuben and this recipe sounds AMAZING!! Is there much a muchness between Vegan Mayo and Normal Mayo flavouriwse? Have a fabulous day!
    xx Bry Jaimea | bryjaimea.com

    Reply

    • Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (28) Kristin 04.02.2019

      I really don’t think so! I use it in tuna salad, homemade ranch dressing, etc and have never noticed anything off or different about it. :)

      Reply

Free Email Series

Dinner Made EASY

5 days of simple yet flavorful recipes that take the stress out of dinnertime!

Subscribe

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (29)

Free Email Series

Dinner Made EASY

5 days of simple yet flavorful recipes that take the stress out of dinnertime!

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (30)

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (31)

hi, i'm kristin!

I’m a Midwestern wife and Mama, and after being diagnosed with Celiac Disease in 2013 I began sharing delicious and approachable gluten-free recipes made with everyday, in-season ingredients. Welcome!

Learn More

Reuben Chicken - Mouthwatering Chicken Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What makes chicken more juicy? ›

Brines and marinades help tenderize the meat by bringing more moisture in the protein. With that extra moisture, you lose less when you cook. The simplest way to do this is with a dry brine — unwrap the chicken breasts, salt them on both sides and let them sit in the fridge for at least an hour.

How to make chicken juicy inside? ›

Make sure your chicken breast is well-seasoned before adding it to the pan. Cook each side evenly until brown. Once done, bake the chicken breast in a pre-heated oven until juices run clear. The crispy skin from the sear will help keep juices intact while baking cooks the insides through without drying them out.

How to make chicken taste delicious? ›

Marinating is good for flavouring and tenderising your chicken at the same time. It's best to marinate your chicken overnight to give the flavours plenty of time to infuse. A faster way to add flavour is to simply brine your chicken in salty water prior to cooking.

Does soaking chicken in water make it juicy? ›

The process of soaking the meat in salted water causes the chicken to absorb some of the water through osmosis, making it moister when cooked. You can also work with dry brines, which lead to crispy skin and keep the natural moisture in the bird without the hassle of a wet brine.

How do you cook chicken so it doesn't dry out? ›

Make the chicken thinner

Thinner breasts or cutlets are less likely to dry out, as they won't spend as much time in the pan. A simple option is to pound the chicken until it is 1/4 to 1/2 inch thick, using a meat mallet/pounder, heavy skillet or even a hammer. This is best done between parchment paper or plastic wrap.

How to make chicken soft and juicy while cooking? ›

Here are four simple steps you can follow to make your chicken dishes as juicy, flavorful, and tender as possible:
  1. Debone the pieces of meat. To tenderize pieces of chicken, you'll need to remove any bones left in the meat. ...
  2. Pound the poultry. ...
  3. Marinate your chicken. ...
  4. Cook at an adequate temperature.
Oct 8, 2021

What should you season chicken with? ›

Aside from classics like salt, pepper, basil and garlic, you could try using chilli powder, ginger, cumin, cayenne, paprika, oregano, sage, rosemary and thyme.

Does soaking chicken in salt water make it juicy? ›

Brining is the process whereby chicken (or other meat) is submerged in a salty liquid (“brine”) and left to marinate to add flavour, tenderise AND add moisture so the chicken stays juicier when roasted.

What brings out the flavor in chicken? ›

Use a brine

Brining your chicken is a foolproof way to not only add flavour to your roast but also to ensure you don't overcook the meat. Essentially a mix of salt, sugar and water, we love adding herbs, garlic or whole spices such as fennel and cumin to flavour the brine.

What spices enhance the flavor of chicken? ›

5 best spice and herbs blends for chicken and meat
  • Paprika and garlic powder. Paprika is a great spice that makes any chicken dish stand out, it comes in many forms sweet, hot, regular and smoky. ...
  • Basil and rosemary. ...
  • Ginger and lemongrass. ...
  • Turmeric and chili. ...
  • Coriander and cumin.

Why is my chicken not tasty? ›

To taste good, chicken must be cooked on the bone yet so much of what is sold is cooked in the form of filleted thighs and breast which is just tasteless, dry and awful. Chicken is tastier than turkey, I guess. Both need some flavoring additives to make them tastier than if nothing is added.

Why is my chicken not juicy? ›

The Role of Temperature and Cooking Time

The key to cooking chicken without drying it out is finding the sweet spot between temperature and cooking time. When you cook chicken at a high temperature, the muscle fibers of the chicken contract rapidly, causing moisture loss.

How to season chicken like a restaurant? ›

Mix together salt, paprika, onion powder, thyme, white pepper, black pepper, cayenne pepper, and garlic powder in a small bowl; set aside. Remove and discard giblets from chicken. Rinse chicken cavity; pat dry with paper towels. Rub each chicken inside and out with spice mixture.

How to cook chicken like a chef? ›

How to Make Perfectly Cooked Chicken Breasts
  1. Season the chicken breasts with salt and black pepper on both sides.
  2. Add olive oil to a sauté pan over high heat. ...
  3. Heat the oil until it begins to smoke lightly. ...
  4. Add the chicken breasts, turn the heat to medium-high, and cook them for 3 ½ to 4 minutes.
Oct 23, 2023

What makes chicken soft and juicy? ›

Convection cooking will get you there much more gently and safely, and make it much easier to get the meat juicy and tender. So, sear in the pan and finish in the oven; or char on the grill on high, then drop the heat to low and close the lid to let it finish cooking through.

Why is my chicken always dry? ›

The Role of Temperature and Cooking Time

When you cook chicken at a high temperature, the muscle fibers of the chicken contract rapidly, causing moisture loss. However, if you cook your chicken too low and slow, the fibers will break down, resulting in a mushy, dry texture.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 5731

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.